SAP Commissions
Comparing transparency: spreadsheets vs. incentive compensation software
Comparing Transparency: Spreadsheets vs. Incentive Compensation Software

Table Of Contents

In this article, we delve into the world of incentive compensation calculation, comparing the transparency of two common solutions: spreadsheet and incentive compensation software.

Here’s what you can expect to learn:

  1. What is incentive compensation: definition of incentive compensation
  2. How to calculate incentive compensation: methods and factors involved in calculating incentive compensation
  3. What is sales spreadsheets: role of sales spreadsheets in tracking and managing sales data.
  4. Incentive compensation in spreadsheet
  5. Transparency in spreadsheet calculations: evaluate the transparency of calculating incentive compensation in spreadsheets and the factors that influence it.
  6. What is sales commission software: learn about sales commission software and its advantages in managing compensation plans.
  7. Incentive compensation tools: insights into dedicated incentive compensation tools and their role in enhancing transparency and efficiency.
  8. Transparency in incentive compensation tools calculations: evaluate the transparency and the factors that influence it.

What is incentive compensation

Incentive compensation refers to the financial rewards granted to salespeople based on various performance metrics, including the quantity of products sold and additional factors such as team success, contract duration, contract value, and overall organizational performance.

Typically, incentive compensation packages comprise three primary components: a base salary, commission, and supplementary monetary incentives. These components are structured to encourage and incentivize sales representatives to not only meet but also exceed predefined sales targets and quotas.

How to calculate incentive compensation

Calculating employee incentive compoenstaion is not a one-size-fits-all process. Companies customize their sales plans based on several variables, such as the nature of their products or services, the complexity of sales efforts, product demand, and cost considerations.

One of the simplest methods for calculation an incentive payment is to first ascertain the total sales generated by an sales rep, establish a bonus percentage, and then multiply the total sales figure by the designated bonus percentage. However, it’s important to note that many organizations have specific guidelines and additional factors that must be considered in the calculation of incentive compensation, depending on their unique corporate rules and policies.

In this article we explain more about mixed pay and calculation of it.

What is sales spreadsheet

A spreadsheet stands out as one of the most accessible tools for incentive compensation calculations. It enjoys universal availability, with sales reps worldwide having easy access to it. The uniformity of formulas simplifies calculations and expedites the process of incentive calculation. It’s no surprise that spreadsheets are the go-to choice for crafting sales compensation templates.

Spreadsheets serve as invaluable resources for tracking and managing sales data. They offer versatility that appeals to businesses of all scales, aiding in the organization, analysis, and monitoring of diverse aspects within their sales operations.

Incentive compensation in spreadsheet

Calculating incentive compensation in a spreadsheet can be relatively easy or complex, depending on the complexity of your incentive plan and the spreadsheet skills of the person working on it. With low level of formula complexity and small companies for sure spreadsheets are advanced enough to track sales and calculate commissions, but you need to consider that spreadsheets have:

A limited audit trail

While spreadsheets can track changes made to formulas or data, they may not offer the same level of detailed audit trails as dedicated ICM solutions. This can make it challenging to track and review changes made to compensation calculations and decisions over time.

A potential for errors

Spreadsheets are more susceptible to human error due to manual data entry, formula mistakes, or accidental changes. These errors can impact the transparency of compensation calculations and create confusion or disputes.

Poor data security

Spreadsheets may have limitations in terms of data security and access controls. If not properly managed, there is a risk of unauthorized access or accidental sharing of sensitive compensation data, compromising transparency and confidentiality.

Transparency in spreadsheet calculations

Considering those points, for medium and large enterprises with complex incentive compensation plans, using spreadsheets can pose significant transparency challenges. The degree of transparency in incentive compensation calculations within a spreadsheet hinges on factors like the spreadsheet’s design, documentation, and communication within the organization.

There is a notable risk of data security breaches, a heightened likelihood of errors that can be challenging to detect, and limited audit capabilities associated with spreadsheets. These concerns underscore the importance of considering alternative, more specialized tools for managing intricate incentive compensation structures in larger organizations.

What is sales compensation software

Sales compensation management software is a set of tools and programs that helps streamlining and automating incentive compensation procedures. These compensation software solutions offer a comprehensive suite of tools that facilitate the creation, execution, and monitoring of personalized incentive compensation plans for every sales reps.

Incentive compensation tools

There is a variety of available incentive compensation tools, depending on company needs and requirements. These tools range from elementary functionalities that ensure fast incentive compensation calculation, rapid sales report generation, and transparent audit trail visibility, to advanced, multi-tiered solutions designed to swiftly and accurately calculate sales commission plans for a large sales force.

These compensation tools not only calculate commission calculations but also assist in sales planning, leveraging historical data for future sales forecasts. They aid in territory allocation among sales teams and offer a set of connectors to seamlessly integrate with external programs, expediting sales processes.

Read also our pro tips to organize processes and increase sales.

The ideal sales commission software is one that aligns smoothly with your company’s specific needs and objectives.

Incentive compensation management solutions provide:

High level of data transparency

a higher level of transparency compared to spreadsheets. They offer built-in reporting and analytics capabilities that allow stakeholders to access real-time data on compensation calculations, performance metrics, and payout details. This transparency helps build employee and managerial trust and ensures that compensation decisions are based on accurate and objective information.

Audit trails

Incentive compensation tools maintain detailed audit trails that track changes, approvals, and modifications made to compensation plans and calculations. This audit trail provides a clear record of actions taken, making it easier to investigate discrepancies or address any concerns about transparency.

 Clear rules and visibility

Incentive compensation management software allow organizations to define clear and standardized rules for incentive compensation calculations. These rules are typically configurable within the software, ensuring consistency and transparency across the organization. Additionally, participants have visibility into their individual performance metrics, goals, and how their compensation is calculated.

Access controls

Commission software often offer role-based access controls, ensuring that only authorized individuals have access to sensitive compensation data. This helps maintain data integrity and protects confidential information while allowing relevant stakeholders to view compensation information within their designated roles.

Transparency in incentive compensation tools calculations

Incentive compensation software provides a superior level of transparency and auditability for incentive compensation calculations. It enhances data visibility and ensures controlled access, thereby restricting the ability of individuals in various roles within the company to modify the established rules within the system.

To make an informed choice between the two options, consider your organization’s specific sales rules and whether transparency in sales compensation data is a concern. Conduct a thorough review of your compensation needs, aligning them with your company’s requirements and the complexity of your sales compensation structures. This holistic approach will guide you towards the most suitable solution for your unique circumstances.

Check our article about important things to consider when choosing a provider of sales compensation calculation tool.

Check what is the real cost of errors in sales commission calculation.

Need an incentive pyment glossary? Here you will find basic one.

You can always contact to experienced SANDS Partners consultants. You will find our contact information and a contact questionnaire here.

Get in touch with an ICM Expert
We're here to support your Incentive Compensation Management journey.
Leave us a message and we'll get back to you.
Copyright © 2024 Sands Partners. All rights reserved. Privacy policy.